Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty Recipe

Imagine the most delightful collision of sweet nostalgia and zesty freshness, and you’ll land right at the heart of this Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty. This dreamy treat is my sunshine-in-a-glass recipe, blending bright orange with a swoosh of vanilla creaminess for the ultimate frosty experience. The best part? With just a handful of simple ingredients and a blender, you can whip up a homemade version that’s so close to the real thing, you might just find it becomes your new go-to dessert. Whether you want to cool down on a hot day or satisfy a creamsicle craving, this creamy, citrusy creation never disappoints.

Ingredients You’ll Need

The magic of the Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty is that every ingredient is as straightforward as it is essential. Together, these simple pantry and fridge staples form that unbeatable texture and signature flavor we all crave. Each one has a starring role—don’t skip or substitute unless you’re feeling adventurous!

• Freshly squeezed or store-bought orange juice: For real orange flavor and vibrant color, start with quality juice; you’ll use some to freeze as cubes and some to blend.
• Cool Whip or vanilla Greek yogurt: Cool Whip gives the classic, fluffy Frosty texture, while yogurt is a dreamy alternative for a tangy, creamy twist.
• Sweetened condensed milk: This ingredient layers in rich sweetness and contributes a silky finish; adjust to taste for just the right balance.

How to Make Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty

Step 1: Prepare Orange Juice Ice Cubes

Pour about 100 ml of your orange juice into an ice cube tray, then slide it into the freezer overnight. These cubes pack a tangy punch and ensure that your Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty is thick, cold, and never watered down.

Step 2: Combine Ingredients in Blender

Once your orange juice cubes are solid, pop them out and toss them into your blender. Add the Cool Whip or vanilla Greek yogurt, sweetened condensed milk, and the remaining orange juice. This creates the luscious base for that signature creamy, citrus flavor.

Step 3: Blend Frosty Mixture

Blend all the ingredients together until you have a thick, uniform, and super smooth mixture. It should be the texture of a classic Frosty—spoonable, but with just enough softness to slurp through a straw. Take care not to over-blend, as too much blending introduces excess heat and melts the magic!

Step 4: Adjust Consistency

If you like your Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty a bit firmer (I do!), just pop the whole blender jar into the freezer for 5 to 10 minutes. This little rest thickens things up beautifully and keeps everything frosty.

Step 5: Serve Frosty

When it’s time to dig in, grab a chilled glass or dessert cup, pour in your creation, and hand yourself a straw or spoon. That first taste—the creamy vanilla meeting tangy orange—is pure happiness. Enjoy it immediately before it melts!

How to Serve Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty

Garnishes

For a burst of extra color and texture, try topping your Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty with a twist of orange zest, a fresh orange wheel, or even a sprinkle of crushed vanilla wafers. These little flourishes give your frosty a dash of flair and hint at the citrus magic within.

Side Dishes

Pair your frosty with a simple shortbread cookie or a crisp biscotti on the side—the buttery, crunchy cookies balance perfectly with the citrusy cream. If you’re in a snacking mood, serve alongside a fresh fruit salad for a dreamy, refreshing afternoon treat.

Creative Ways to Present

Turn the Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty into a showstopper by pouring it into mini dessert glasses for a party, swirling on a cloud of whipped cream, or even sandwiching scoops between soft sugar cookies for a handmade creamsicle sandwich. Kids (and adults) go wild for these playful presentations!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Have extra Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty? Simply transfer any leftovers to an airtight container and refrigerate for up to two days. Whisk or stir before serving again, as the mixture may separate slightly.

Freezing

If you want to keep some on hand for a treat later in the week, freeze the frosty mixture in a sealed container. When you’re ready to enjoy, let it sit at room temperature for a few minutes to soften, then give it a quick blend to restore that smooth, creamy consistency.

Reheating

This chilly treat is best enjoyed cold, so reheating isn’t necessary. If your Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty is too firm straight from the freezer, let it thaw gently on the counter and stir until scoopable or sippable.

FAQs

Can I use all Greek yogurt instead of Cool Whip?

Absolutely! Using vanilla Greek yogurt in place of Cool Whip gives a tangier flavor and a slight protein boost. Your Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty will be just as luscious and creamy, with a fresh twist.

What if I don’t have sweetened condensed milk?

You can use evaporated milk plus a tablespoon or two of sugar as a quick substitute in a pinch, but sweetened condensed milk delivers that signature richness and sweetness you expect. For best results, stick to the original ingredient.

Can I make this dairy free?

Yes! Choose a dairy-free whipped topping and a plant-based yogurt. For the sweetened condensed milk, use a coconut-based or oat-based alternative. The result is a vegan Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty with all the creamy, citrusy joy.

Do I have to freeze the orange juice cubes overnight?

Freezing overnight gives the best results, but a minimum of 4 to 6 hours will work if you’re short on time. The firmer the cubes, the thicker and frostier your final treat will be.

Can I use other citrus juices?

While orange juice is classic, feel free to experiment with tangerine or blood orange juice for an extra-special twist on the traditional Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty. Just keep the proportions the same and get ready to swoon over the results!

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for a little nostalgia and a lot of flavor, I can’t recommend this Wendy’s Creamsicle Frosty enough. It’s easy, quick, and delivers pure joy in every bite. Go ahead—treat yourself and share with your favorite people! Your blender is waiting.

Print