Best Pimento Cheese Recipe

If you’ve been searching high and low for the best combination of creamy, tangy, and savory Southern spread, this Best Pimento Cheese recipe is going to sweep you off your feet. Rich cheddar meets dreamy cream cheese and those quintessential sweet-yet-sassy pimentos, making every bite an explosion of flavor and texture. Whether you’re slathering it on crackers, slinging it into sandwiches, or just sneaking spoonfuls from the fridge, this is truly the Best Pimento Cheese you’ll ever have—get ready to fall in love with a classic all over again!

Ingredients You’ll Need

Each ingredient in the Best Pimento Cheese brings something uniquely wonderful to the table—trust me, the balance is everything! From freshly grated cheddar to silky cream cheese and vibrant pimentos, every component works together to create irresistible flavor and spreadability.

• Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Freshly grated is essential here for the melty, bold cheesy flavor and that classic pimento cheese texture.
• Cream Cheese: Make sure it’s very soft and at room temperature so it blends smoothly into the spread.
• Real Mayonnaise: A high-quality mayo like Dukes adds that authentic Southern creaminess—skip the Miracle Whip for this one.
• Garlic Powder: Lends a subtle savory depth that enhances all the other flavors without overpowering them.
• Onion Powder: Just the right hint of onion-y warmth to round everything out.
• Diced Pimentos: That little jar brings brightness and a hint of sweetness—you’ll see why they’re the star of the show.
• Paprika, Black Pepper, Salt, and Cayenne (Optional): Season to taste for the perfect balance of flavor and just a touch of heat if you like things zippy.

How to Make Best Pimento Cheese

Step 1: Gather and Prep Your Ingredients

Start by grating your sharp cheddar cheese—really, do this by hand! Pre-grated just can’t compare, because it lacks that super-fresh texture and deep flavor that makes the Best Pimento Cheese stand out. Make sure your cream cheese is very soft (a short rest on the countertop does wonders), and drain your jar of diced pimentos so your spread isn’t watery.

Step 2: Mix Everything Together

Grab a medium bowl and add the grated cheddar, cream cheese, mayonnaise, garlic powder, onion powder, and drained pimentos. Blend it all up, either using a sturdy wooden spoon for a chunkier texture, or a hand mixer if you like things ultra-smooth and creamy. This is your moment to taste and adjust seasonings—add a sprinkle of paprika for color, black pepper or cayenne if you want a gentle kick, and salt if needed. Every batch can be personalized!

Step 3: Chill and Let Flavors Mingle

Once everything is fully mixed, cover the bowl with plastic wrap and pop it in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours. This chilling time is crucial: it allows all those cheddar, garlic, and pimento flavors to meld together into true Southern glory. Trust me, patience is a virtue here—taste it after chilling and you’ll never look back.

How to Serve Best Pimento Cheese

Garnishes

A little flourish goes a long way! Sprinkle some extra paprika or thinly sliced green onions on top for a pop of color and freshness. If you want to make it extra fancy, a few ribbons of roasted red pepper or a dusting of chives can make every scoop look swoon-worthy and party-ready.

Side Dishes

The Best Pimento Cheese loves good company. Serve it with crisp celery sticks, crunchy crackers, or rustic crostini. Pile it high on soft white bread for a classic sandwich, or pair with a tangy dill pickle and kettle chips for that true lunch-counter nostalgia. It’s a perfect addition to any picnic or potluck spread, too!

Creative Ways to Present

This spread is made for more than just basic sandwiches! Scoop it into mini bell pepper halves for cute appetizer bites, swirl it on baked potatoes, layer it in burgers, or even melt it into your next batch of mac and cheese for a Southern twist. Every serving of Best Pimento Cheese offers a chance to play and experiment—just have fun with it!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Leftover Best Pimento Cheese will stay delicious and fresh if stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator. It usually keeps well for about 5-7 days, but honestly, I doubt it will stick around that long! Always give it a good stir before serving again to revive its creamy texture.

Freezing

While technically you can freeze pimento cheese, I don’t really recommend it—the texture can become a bit grainy after thawing due to the cheese and mayo. If you do decide to freeze, pack it tightly in a freezer-safe container, and plan to use it within a month. Let it thaw overnight in the fridge and give it a serious stir before enjoying.

Reheating

Pimento cheese is typically served chilled or at room temp, so you usually don’t need to reheat it. But if you’re using it on something warm, like grits or baked potatoes, simply scoop out what you need and let it come to room temperature for the best spreadability. Avoid microwaving, as it can separate the creamy base.

FAQs

Can I use pre-shredded cheddar instead of grating it myself?

Freshly grated cheddar makes a big difference in flavor and creamy texture for the Best Pimento Cheese—pre-shredded is coated in anti-caking agents and just won’t deliver the same rich results. Take the extra few minutes to shred your own; it’s worth it!

What’s the best way to adjust the spice level?

Start small with cayenne and black pepper, and taste as you go. If you like a bit more heat, add another pinch or two of cayenne or a splash of your favorite hot sauce—it’s all about finding your perfect kick in this Best Pimento Cheese.

Can I use low-fat ingredients?

You can substitute low-fat cream cheese or mayonnaise if you prefer, but your Best Pimento Cheese may have a slightly different (less creamy) texture and a milder flavor. If you do, try balancing with a touch more seasoning or fresh herbs for added zest.

How long should I chill the pimento cheese before serving?

Chilling for at least 2 hours is best—it’s when all the flavors come together and the cheese absorbs the seasoning. Overnight is even better if you can plan ahead, especially if you’re making it for a special occasion!

Can I double the recipe for a crowd?

Absolutely! Just increase each ingredient proportionally and mix in a large bowl. The Best Pimento Cheese is always a hit at parties, potlucks, and tailgates, so don’t be surprised when you run out fast!

Final Thoughts

I just know that once you dive into a bowl of this Best Pimento Cheese, you’ll understand why it’s such a loved staple on Southern tables—and why it might become a new favorite at yours, too. Try it for your next gathering or a cozy night in, and see how quickly it disappears!

Print