Southern Buttermilk Pie Recipe

Southern Buttermilk Pie is that timeless Southern dessert that wraps you up in comfort and nostalgia with every bite. Its custardy, creamy filling sits beautifully in a flaky pie crust, while hints of vanilla and a whisper of nutmeg make it irresistibly fragrant. This pie is a true celebration of simplicity, letting each ingredient shine through and creating a treat you’ll want to share with friends and family over coffee, holidays, or just because. If you’re searching for an easy yet impressive sweet ending, Southern Buttermilk Pie is simply unforgettable.

Ingredients You’ll Need

The ingredients for Southern Buttermilk Pie are delightfully humble, but their flavors come together in perfect harmony. Each one is crucial for achieving that signature creamy texture, golden color, and just-sweet-enough taste you’ll crave again and again.

• Pie crust (1 9-inch deep dish, frozen or homemade): Serves as the buttery, flaky foundation that holds all the luscious filling together.
• Granulated sugar (1 1/2 cups): Provides the perfect level of sweetness and helps create that slight caramelization along the top.
• All-purpose flour (3 Tbsp): Gives a little body to the filling so it sets up soft but not runny.
• Salt (1/4 tsp): Enhances all the flavors and keeps the sweetness in check.
• Ground nutmeg (1/8 tsp plus more for topping): Adds a warm, aromatic hint that sets this pie apart.
• Buttermilk (1 cup, not fat free, room temperature): The star of the show, delivering tangy creaminess and that signature Southern profile.
• Butter (1/2 cup, melted and cooled): Makes the filling ultra-rich and perfectly smooth.
• Eggs (3 large, room temperature): Bind everything together and provide that beautiful custardy structure.
• Lemon juice (1 Tbsp): Brightens the filling and balances the richness.
• Pure vanilla extract (1 tsp): Brings out the classic dessert aroma you expect in a homemade pie.
• Whipped cream (optional for serving): Adds a light, fluffy finish if you want to make each slice extra special.

How to Make Southern Buttermilk Pie

Step 1: Prep the Oven and Pie Crust

Preheat your oven to 350°F so it’s properly hot and ready for baking. Place your pie crust (whether you’re using store-bought or homemade) on a baking sheet. This not only makes it easier to move in and out of the oven, but it also helps catch any spills that might bubble over.

Step 2: Mix the Dry Ingredients

In a medium mixing bowl, sift or whisk together the granulated sugar, all-purpose flour, salt, and ground nutmeg. This simple step ensures your dry ingredients are well combined and lump-free, giving your filling that silky texture.

Step 3: Combine the Wet Ingredients

Take another bowl and whisk together the buttermilk, melted (but cooled) butter, eggs, lemon juice, and vanilla extract until totally smooth. This blend creates the rich custard base that makes Southern Buttermilk Pie so legendary.

Step 4: Bring It All Together

Gradually whisk your wet mixture into the dry ingredients until you have a creamy, lump-free filling. Pour the mixture evenly into your waiting pie shell, then sprinkle a touch more nutmeg over the top for that golden, fragrant finish.

Step 5: Bake to Perfection

Carefully slide the baking sheet into the oven and bake for 50 to 60 minutes, or until the center of the pie is set but still slightly wobbly when gently shaken. After about 30 minutes, check the edges of the crust and cover them with foil if they’re browning too quickly. This step ensures every bite is just right—golden and firm, with no burnt edges.

Step 6: Cool Completely

Once baked, remove the pie from the oven and let it cool on a wire rack until it reaches room temperature. This helps the custard finish setting, so you get clean slices instead of runny pieces.

Step 7: Chill and Serve

For the dreamiest texture, chill the pie in the fridge before serving—cold Southern Buttermilk Pie is a true Southern treat! Add a dollop of whipped cream, if you like, and savor every silky-smooth, tangy-sweet forkful.

How to Serve Southern Buttermilk Pie

Garnishes

Southern Buttermilk Pie looks lovely on its own, but a light dusting of extra nutmeg or a cloud of whipped cream can dress it up beautifully. Fresh berries, a few lemon zest curls, or even a light drizzle of honey turn each slice into a special occasion.

Side Dishes

This pie pairs delightfully with fresh fruit salads, a scoop of vanilla ice cream, or even a handful of toasted pecans. A cup of coffee or sweet iced tea on the side completes that classic Southern dessert experience.

Creative Ways to Present

Consider serving Southern Buttermilk Pie in mini tart shells for parties, or cut the pie into thin bars for easy sharing at potlucks. For a fun twist, stack small triangles with layers of whipped cream and berries between each for a pretty deconstructed presentation.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Cover any leftovers with plastic wrap or foil and keep them chilled in the fridge. Southern Buttermilk Pie stays fresh for up to four days, maintaining that irresistible creamy texture.

Freezing

You can absolutely freeze Southern Buttermilk Pie! Wrap the whole pie (or individual slices) well in plastic and foil, and freeze for up to two months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving for best results.

Reheating

While this pie is fantastic served cold, you can reheat individual slices in the microwave for about 20 seconds if you prefer it slightly warm. Just avoid over-heating or the custard texture may become uneven.

FAQs

Can I use a store-bought pie crust for Southern Buttermilk Pie?

Yes, a frozen or refrigerated deep dish crust makes preparation super convenient, and you’ll still get wonderful results. If you’re feeling ambitious, homemade crust adds an extra-special touch!

What if I don’t have buttermilk?

If you’re in a pinch, add one tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar to a measuring cup, fill to one cup with whole milk, let it sit five minutes, and you’ll have an easy substitute with the necessary tang for Southern Buttermilk Pie.

Is it best served warm or cold?

The classic way to enjoy this pie is cold or at room temperature, which allows the custard to set completely and the flavors to really shine. That said, a slightly warm slice is lovely too if that’s your preference!

Why does my pie have brown spots on top?

Small golden or brown spots are completely normal and a sign of successful caramelization from the sugar and butter. They add a bit of character and toasty flavor to your Southern Buttermilk Pie.

Can I make this pie in advance for an event?

Absolutely! In fact, making it a day ahead allows the flavors to meld and the custard to firm up, making for the perfect slice when you’re ready to serve. Just keep it chilled until you’re ready to enjoy.

Final Thoughts

There’s something magical about sharing a homemade Southern Buttermilk Pie with people you care about. Each slice serves up creamy comfort with a sweet Southern twist, and it couldn’t be simpler to make. Give this recipe a try—once you taste just how good it is, you’ll find yourself making it for every special occasion and cozy night in.

Print